A 6%-a-month promise: what the SEC alleges in the $560 million Backward Hat case
The SEC says Backward Hat Capital raised $560 million for an FX trading strategy and paid out more than $250 million of it as returns to earlier investors.
The SEC obtained a temporary restraining order and asset freeze on Nov. 20 against Indianapolis-based Backward Hat Capital and its co-founders, Phillip Williams and Devin Johnson. The complaint, filed in the Southern District of Indiana, alleges they raised about $560 million from more than 2,000 investors beginning around July 2022.
The pitch
Investors bought limited partnership interests in private funds. They were told their money would be converted to crypto assets and used for foreign exchange arbitrage by a proprietary, “AI-driven” high-frequency algorithm. The promised return was at least 6% a month. A network of promoters sold the interests, and the SEC says Williams solicited some of his own advisory clients from a former employer. Johnson is alleged to have widened the offering through two further vehicles, AI Capital and Traders Point Capital.
Where the SEC says the money went
According to the complaint, more than $220 million went to Williams and Johnson and more than $250 million went back to earlier investors as purported returns. The SEC lists exotic cars, expensive homes, unrelated businesses and Johnson’s gambling among the uses.
The audit reports
A fifth defendant, Joseph Anderson, is alleged to have produced at least two “audit reports” and a “quality of earnings” report under the name of a supposedly independent audit firm. The reports said returns had been verified against bank and brokerage records. The SEC alleges that Anderson and his company did no real audit work, were not independent, held financial stakes in the scheme, and that the reports conflicted with the bank records.
Three agencies at once
The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York has charged Williams and Johnson criminally. The CFTC has charged Williams, Johnson and several Backward Hat entities. The SEC’s own claims are under the antifraud provisions of the Securities Act and the Exchange Act, with Advisers Act claims against Williams and Traders Point. For readers who follow derivatives regulation, the case is an example of the SEC and CFTC filing in parallel, which the two agencies formalized in a memorandum of understanding during fiscal 2026.
What a reader can take from it
Six percent a month compounds to roughly 100% a year. No FX arbitrage strategy that produced that reliably would need outside money from 2,000 retail investors. An audit report is only as good as the auditor: check that the firm exists, is registered with the PCAOB if it audits public companies or broker-dealers, and has no stake in the fund. Ask who holds custody of the assets and get statements from that custodian directly.
Sponsor’s view
From Andy Altahawi, Adamson Brothers Corp., the sponsor of this publication. In an offering I work on, the auditor, the custodian and the transfer agent are separate firms that I can call. That separation is the whole point of having gatekeepers. The allegation here that the person signing the audit reports had money in the scheme is the detail I would want every private fund investor to read twice. Due diligence on a private placement starts with the service providers, before the strategy.
Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.